Do English Setters make good guard dogs?

No, English Setters generally do not make good guard dogs.

Are English Setters the right size to be guard dogs?

The English Setter has an elegant yet strong medium-to-large build standing 25 inches tall at the shoulder. However their physique prioritizes stamina over confrontational capability.

Does a English Setter have the right temperament to be a guard dog?

This affectionate, energetic breed is very people-oriented and tends to readily accept strangers rather than exhibit wariness or territorial behaviors crucial in a guard dog.

Can you train a English Setter to be a guard dog?

English Setters are moderately intelligent and trainabe, especially when food motivated. However their excitability can distract from training. Protective aggression often counters their friendly nature as well.

Have English Setters ever been used as guard dogs?

Primarily utilized as gundogs for locating and pointing upland gamebirds, English Setters may loudly alert to disturbances but will warmly greet any visitor. Protective roles contradict their nature.

What are the Pros and Cons of using a English Setter as a guard dog?


  • Athleticism
  • Lively and friendly


  • Excitable and easily distracted
  • Overly friendly with strangers
  • Require extensive daily exercise

With their overt affection towards people and high-energy disposition, most English Setters lack both the protective instincts and focus to reliably fulfill guard duties without distraction. Their strengths shine as energetic sporting companions instead.

Final Thoughts

English Setters need long daily on-leash walks or off-leash runs paired with substantial human interaction. A securely-fenced yard provides additional activity as well.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *