Do Shetland Sheepdogs make good guard dogs?

No. Shelties lack adequate protective instinct, intimidating physique and wariness of strangers to serve effectively as guard dogs.

Are Shetland Sheepdogs the right size to be guard dogs?

Shelties are graceful medium-sized herders. Though agile, they lack physical impressiveness and their lush coat contributes a softness unsuitable for threatening appearance.

Does a Shetland Sheepdog have the right temperament to be a guard dog?

Bred to gently herd sheep, Shelties bond closely with “their” people while remaining politely reserved with strangers. They tend to be gentle rather than protective by nature.

Can you train a Shetland Sheepdog to be a guard dog?

Exceptionally bright and eager to please, Shelties respond readily to training. However their politeness and lack of suspicion or aggression toward strangers conflicts with guarding wariness.

Have Shetland Sheepdogs ever been used as guard dogs?

Shelties have a long history as devoted farm and family dogs, but not as property or estate protectors due to their inheritable gentleness and lack of territorialism.

What are the Pros and Cons of using a Shetland Sheepdog as a guard dog?


  • Affectionate and loyal with family
  • Biddable and highly intelligent


  • Overly reserved with strangers rather than aggressive
  • Inadequate size/physicality for protection work

The Shetland Sheepdog’s devoted yet gentle nature may allow them to serve as watchdogs announcing visitors but precludes suitability as guard dogs requiring intimidating presence and protective behaviors.

Final Thoughts

Shelties have very high grooming requirements to prevent matting and may display chasing/herding behaviors requiring management around livestock or small pets. Their emotional sensitivity also means they should not be left alone for long periods.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *