Do Smooth Collies make good guard dogs?

No, the Smooth Collie would not make a reliable guard dog due to their friendly nature and lack of aggressive guarding instincts.

Are Smooth Collies the right size to be guard dogs?

The Smooth Collie is an athletic working breed of medium size. Though agile, they lack the imposing physical traits to intimidate intruders as guard dogs.

Does a Smooth Collie have the right temperament to be a guard dog?

While devoted to family members, Smooth Collies tend to be welcoming towards strangers and non-aggressive in demeanor, contrary to ideal guard dog traits.

Can you train a Smooth Collie to be a guard dog?

Smooth Collies are highly responsive to training and eager to please due to their working background. However, eliciting wary guarding behaviors would be contrary to their affable nature.

Have Smooth Collies ever been used as guard dogs?

Smooth Collies share much of their history with the Rough Collie as capable herding dogs. They continue to excel more at organized dog sports than personal protection roles.

What are the Pros and Cons of using a Smooth Collie as a guard dog?


  • Athleticism and agility
  • Eagerness to please owners


  • Non-imposing physical traits
  • Overly friendly with strangers
  • Not suitable for protection roles

With their affectionate and gentle temperament towards people, Smooth Collies are poorly suited for the demanding roles of guard dogs expected to intimidate and confront intruders.

Final Thoughts

Smooth Collies require extensive socialization to dampen their natural inclination to herd running children through nippy behaviors – making them ill-suited as guardians of homes with kids.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *